Volkswagen's Competitors Weigh In On Emissions Cheating Scandal

As the penalties for Volkswagen’s environmental cheating are being figured out, some significant players in the industry are offering their own thoughts on what should happen to VW.

Back in December, a group of 45 leaders across the business and environmental sectors sent an open letter to the California Air Resources Board (also called CARB) with some different perspectives on what VW should be directed to do.  The most notable member of the group was Tesla and SpaceX founder Elon Musk.

 “Cure the air, not the cars” was their point.

This group of leaders made a series of interesting points about what Volkswagen should be required to do about fixing the cars in the marketplace.  They suggested that VW shouldn’t have to recall and fix those cars, because it was “costly and impractical” and wouldn’t make the cars any safer to drive but would make them run a lot worse (the consumer might view this as being unfair to them, too).

Instead, the group suggested that a better course of action would be take the money that VW would have had to spend fixing old cars and require them to pour those resources into speedier development of “zero emissions” vehicles.

On the face of it, this makes a lot of sense. The whole point for the emissions standards VW got caught cheating is to reduce carbon emissions to improve the environment for future generations. Zero emissions vehicles accomplish this to an even greater extent.

Instead of forcing VW to apply a better bandaid to the problem (by fixing existing diesel cars), make them accelerate the bringing-to-market of even better solutions.

Direct Volkswagen to accelerate the rollout of zero emissions vehicles

Their point here is valid. 

Zero emissions vehicles are better for the environment. The group also made the point that you can’t cheat with these vehicles, plus you save even more because you don’t have to spend money to enforce emissions standards on vehicles that, by definition, don’t emit any emissions.

Require the accelerated rollout to result in greater pollution savings than now, and do it within five years

The five year suggestion puts a time frame on the requirement, an essential step for goal setting if you really intend to do something. But what’s more, they want a 10x greater savings in emissions reduction than what would have been saved if all those diesel vehicles had been properly made. This, too, is logical and stays in step with the real goal of all these standards. It forces VW to do more than they have had to do, and the air quality benefits all the more.

The group had a couple of other suggestions regarding “zero emissions credits” and where they should have to allocate money in California for R&D and manufacturing of these new cars. But this is the crux of it.

Whether or not CARB takes their advice remains to be seen.  But on the face of it, these suggestions seem pretty worthwhile.

You may be interested in these other posts:

• Criminal Test Rigging By Volkswagen
• Car Safety Scandals of Automotive Giant Proportions
• Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel: Great for Emissions - Here’s What's Missing!